Skip to content
Leading Medicine Guide logo

News

Knee replacement: Just how precisely does an implant actually fit these days?

Melanie_Al_Tikriti__BSc.jpg

Melanie Al Tikriti, BSc ·

When the cartilage and joint surfaces of the knee are severely damaged, pain and restricted movement can have a significant impact on our daily lives. If conservative treatments are no longer sufficient, a knee replacement may be considered. Nowadays, modern surgical techniques allow for very precise planning and positioning of the implants. However, precision alone does not determine whether an artificial knee will function well in the long term, as the selection of the appropriate implant, the individual’s physique and rehabilitation also play a significant role.

Knieprothese: Wie präzise sitzt ein Implantat heute wirklich?

Image generated by AI

When is a knee replacement advisable?

A knee replacement is primarily considered in cases of advanced knee osteoarthritis, when pain and functional limitations persist despite non-surgical treatments having been exhausted. For this reason, it is not just the X-ray that is examined beforehand; the actual symptoms and their impact on daily life are also crucial.

Typical reasons for surgery may include:

  • persistent pain despite conservative treatment
  • significant difficulties with walking
  • difficulty climbing stairs
  • increasing loss of mobility
  • significant disruption to daily life and quality of life

The decision to undergo joint replacement should be made on an individual basis, as it is a procedure that cannot easily be reversed.

Partial or total prosthesis?

Not every damaged part of the knee actually needs to be replaced. With a partial prosthesis, only the affected area of the joint is replaced. However, this requires that the condition is limited to a specific section.

With a total knee replacement (TKR), the joint surfaces of the femur and tibia are replaced. Depending on the situation, the posterior surface of the patella may also be treated.

Which option is suitable depends on the extent of the osteoarthritis, knee stability, the leg axis and other anatomical factors.

What are the benefits of navigation and robotics?

In knee replacement surgery, the implant components must be positioned as accurately as possible. Nowadays, modern navigation systems or surgical robots can be used for this purpose. In such robot-assisted procedures, a model of the knee joint is first created. The system then assists the surgical team in planning and executing the bone cuts.

An important distinction: the robot does not operate independently, as many people believe. The medical decision and the performance of the procedure remain the responsibility of the surgical team.

Studies show that robotic systems can improve the positioning of implants. However, this does not lead to better outcomes or less pain. The S3 guideline on knee osteoarthritis also points out that greater precision is not necessarily better for functionality.

Customised knee prosthesis

No two knees are exactly alike. That is why modern procedures take individual anatomical features into account. These include the leg axis, the size and shape of the bone, and the tension of the ligaments. With patient-specific instruments, it is possible to create cutting blocks based on prior imaging in order to achieve the planned position of the implant as accurately as possible.

However, customisation does not mean that a completely unique prosthesis model is manufactured for every patient. Rather, it involves the individually tailored planning and positioning of standardised implant components.

How long does a knee prosthesis last?

As with all prostheses, the lifespan depends on various factors. These include the type of implant, the surgical procedure, the level of strain, body weight and the patient’s age at the time of surgery.

Modern knee prostheses can function for many years, but there is no guarantee of a specific lifespan. Over time, for example, the anchoring or other components may change. Infections, injuries or changes in the load on the joint can also cause problems. This is precisely why medical check-ups are important, especially if new symptoms arise.

If your knee hurts after the operation

Pain and swelling are not unusual following knee replacement surgery, as the knee understandably needs to adjust to the new joint situation. Physiotherapy helps to restore mobility and rebuild muscle strength. However, persistent or worsening pain should be investigated. Possible causes range from delayed rehabilitation and problems with ligament tension to loosening of the prosthesis or infection.

A feeling of instability, recurring swelling or significantly restricted mobility may also be reasons for further investigation. The fact is, not every painful knee prosthesis automatically needs to be replaced. First of all, the cause must be determined as accurately as possible.

Conclusion: Precision for a better quality of life

Modern knee replacements can be planned and fitted with great precision. Navigation and robotics enable technically precise implantation, but they do not replace the experience and judgement of the surgical team. Whether a partial or total prosthesis is required, and which implant position and procedure are suitable, depends on the individual’s anatomy and symptoms. Even after the operation, rehabilitation and careful follow-up care remain crucial.

Share this article

Melanie_Al_Tikriti__BSc.jpg

About the medical author

Melanie Al Tikriti, BSc

Editor

More about the medical author →

News

Read next